People are voting emotionally.

Load of rubbish!!

Don't listen to the negative reviews

a film so unique, intoxicating and bizarre that it not only demands another viewing, but is also forgivable as a satirical comedy where the jokes eventually take the back seat.

This is a great informative show. I like how we are seeing inside and "behind the scenes" of some high profile cases that we may have heard of in the past. In order to be rated higher, I would like to see the result of their investigative work. Such as arrests, incarceration, seizures, search warrants, etc. OR... have some episodes of Breaking Homcide resulting in the apprehension of these criminals. Or even... at the end of the season have one episode dedicated to short tibdits of the follow through of the local PDs. I completely understand if PDs cannot discuss because it's ongoing but heck, that's a great sign it's in progress. That would absolutely be top notch. From the Michelle case (season 1, episode 1), viewing this episode left us angry, frustrated and annoyed that the alleged was not convicted or apprehended. I continue to search on the web for a follow up. And I'm left disappointed. BUT... Overall, great show! I will continue to observe their in-depth work from home.

Unless the local cops were totally inept from the beginning, I wondered if these two guys, who are clearly not detectives, just used the known suspects and evidence, re-interviewed the victims, then took credit for identifying a suspect that was already in police evidence? The tears did bother me some, but the ladies love that kind of fake stuff! I'm done with this boring show.

I usually like the Investigation Discovery shows, watching how the evidence falls into place to nab the killer. So I tuned into this 2-parter of "Who Killed Faith?" without knowing anything about the show. I was SO disappointed. The death of Faith Hedgepeth was already an open murder investigation by the Chapel Hill (NC) Police Department, and they have the forensic evidence. The "detectives" in this show (Derrick Levasseur, former police detective and Kris Mohandie, forensic psychologist) did NOT have access to some of the most pertinent evidence in this case, such as fingerprints and DNA. In addition, they could not even talk to all of their suspects. I still thought they might come up with the killer using old-fashioned investigative work (think Columbo), but to no avail. At the end of the show, they offered their 2 cents (a theory), but that was it. This is a sad excuse for a show and I expect better from Discovery ID.

The closeup of Derrick fake crying ruined season 1 episode 1. Derrick fake cried just like that in his diary room sessions on Big Brother 16 (in addition to lying to the audience). The guy is disingenuous and lacks charisma.