Plot so thin, it passes unnoticed.

Excellent, a Must See

I think this is a new genre that they're all sort of working their way through it and haven't got all the kinks worked out yet but it's a genre that works for me.

.Like the great film, it's made with a great deal of visible affection both in front of and behind the camera.

RIPLEY UNDER GROUND (2005)Tom Wilkinson. Simon Callow. Clare Forlani… The casting is fine with the unfortunate exception of Barry Pepper (excellent in The 25th Hour) who is miscast as Patricia Highsmith's Tom Ripley. Then again, this movie is only nominally a Ripley film. Why, because the misfiring slapstick of the screenplay taken with the frenetic "action" orientation of the pedestrian direction are wrong-headed. And that's a shame. Actors, however competent, cannot save films lacking intelligence, wit, subtlety, and style. Highsmith requires these four things, plus atmosphere. Postcard shots of a French château, jump cuts, and wooden dialogue just don't meet the mark. Nor is mere attitude (for example, an arty archness) any substitute for substance (in this case, the mental machinations of Mr. Ripley). And yet, there are worse movies on offer. Far worse.

I randomly watched the movie in the TV,having no idea what i was going to see. Not bad but pretty fake at some point but even with the the cliché' of trying to be unpredictable,i enjoyed it.Tom Ripley with his friends are trying to hide the death of their talented painter-artist friend and make money out of his name pretending that he is alive but this isn't an easy job to do,Tom Ripley in his try to not be revealed is willing to do anything.....It is an average movie but it keeps your interest to watch it till the end,Barry Pepper's (Tom Ripley)acting was good and Claire Forlani(Cynthia) was the hottest in the movie,i enjoyed her sexy scenes and dialogs the most.So just fine to watch it but yet there is anything great to remember from the movie

This was a decent and entertaining movie in its own right, although (like everyone here) it's hard not to compare it to other previous screen-adaptations of the Ripley stories. Among those there are very notable ones, like "The talented mister Ripley" with Matt Damon, "Plein Soleil" with Alan Delon and "The American Friend" with Dennis Hopper, all with very strong characterizations of Tom Ripley. And then there was the dreadful "Ripley's Game" with John Malkovitch. Well, this "Ripley Underground" stands somewhere in-between, depending on how you look at it. I'm a big fan of the novels of Patricia Highsmith. In the Ripley-series (5 novels) Tom Ripley is as charming as Highsmith's other (anti-)heroes, but he's also a psychopath in the "best" sense of the word: highly intelligent and totally void of any conscience. Highsmith loved to play with the possibilities that a character like this created: devious machinations, ingenious murders and cunning solutions when at times things seemed to turn awry. Another important feature is the unobtrusive way in which Ripley manages all his schemes: he's the quintessential boy-next-door whom no-one suspects of anything bad. Now when you want a scrupulous rendering of Highsmith's novel to the screen, this movie fails. The script did use the premise (the forgery of an already dead painter's work and how master-mind Ripley and his accomplices get away with it) but then gave it all kinds of twists and turns of its own. Also they used all the right names, but gave almost all the protagonists a different characterization from the ones in the novel. Now that is not necessarily bad. In the novel only Ripley himself and Bernard really stand out, the others are a bit bland. Obviously the makers of the movie wanted to give more color to the story and the characters and in this they succeeded. However, as to the Tom Ripley character I have some reservations. Here Tom can hardly be called an unobtrusive boy-next-door, he's actually a very sexy stunner (at many times he walks around shirtless to show-off his chiseled torso to prove so). Moreover he's pictured as an active and sensual lady's man, which the original Ripley is very much NOT, in fact there are countless homosexual innuendo's in all of the Ripley-novels (very convincingly captured in Minghella's "Talented Mr. Ripley"). Again, this doesn't have to make for a bad movie, but it makes you wonder why they should want to use the Highsmith-Ripley character at all, when they change its most essential aspects. Then they had better just used the (strong) premise and fill out the story with a bunch of new characters. Anyway, as a movie of its own right it's fine enough. Here Ripley is a very self-confident, ruthless and charming con-man who sets up a smart scheme of fraud and murder and wriggles his way into the bed and the wealth of a beautiful woman. The pace is fast, the movie has a very modern and metropolitan (London!) feel and besides action and suspense also lots of humor (which is definitely NOT Highsmithian, or it would be her macabre sense of dark humor). Maybe that could have used some better editing, at times it's almost too much of a comedy (like the scene where Tom has to clean the blood of two giant white poodles after a killing). The acting is overall very good, I especially liked Allan Cumming as the exasperated priggish gallery-owner, he's is really great and very funny in all of his scenes. Claire Forlani is beautiful, as is Jacinda Barrett as Heloïse. Wlliam Dafoe's name is prominently on the cover of the DVD, but he only has very limited screen-time and they didn't give him much to put his teeth in. Tom Wilkinson as the intelligent adversary of Tom Ripley did a fine job. Ian Hart was also fine as the misguided and abused Bernard, but I was so distracted by the idiotic hair-do they made him wear (a wig, I hope!) that it very much marred my enjoyment of his part. This leaves Barry Pepper as Tom Ripley. Now you wouldn't call him really handsome, but he has these remarkable features that are classical and rugged at the same time (an exciting combination!), he's charismatic, very physical, and plays the intelligent con-man with much flair and obvious fun. All in all: I liked it, not as a Highsmith, but as a fine and entertaining movie in its own right.

I bought this, cheap on second hand DVD - and I didn't expect much. I had seen: "The talented Mr Ripley" and "Ripleys game" before - so I was a bit curious as to how this one would go down, because I haven't heard anything about it and that is usually a bad sign. - But.... I absolutely LOVED it. The plot was intriguing, and I loved the actors - and the ending - just perfect ! This is a movie I,m gonna watch again in a years time. At the end of this movie I actually raised my arms up and shouted: "Bloody hell!!! GREAT movie !!! There is also a bit of music in the middle of the movie when Tom goes to France I think for the first time - anyone know what music that is? Its beautiful.