I gave it a 7.5 out of 10

Good concept, poorly executed.

The performances transcend the film's tropes, grounding it in characters that feel more complete than this subgenre often produces.

Blistering performances.

The film begins with a man going to his ex-wife's apartment to deliver some frozen meat. However, after looking over her place twice to see if there were any clues as to where she was, he finds her--dead. Apparently she killed herself--and did an amazing job organizing her life for the family. For example, all the food that the family would need for Passover was there--made and labeled in the refrigerator. But, the story has a few hiccups. First, the ex-husband really despised her in many ways. For example, although she was a Jew, he deliberately finds her in a Christian cemetery and with a VERY Christian coffin--talk about passive-aggressive! Second, although I never knew it, apparently some Jews look upon suicide much like many Catholics see it--like it's a mortal sin and you cannot bury such a person in consecrated ground! Really. But, there is one more hitch that unexpectedly develops--something the dead woman did not anticipate--a stray photo.To me, this is a great example of a film that is expertly crafted but lacks one very important thing--a story. So, while I can really admire the acting (particularly Fernando Luján) and the director had a really deft artistic touch, the story itself left me flat--very flat. The biggest problem is that I kept expecting all the story elements to come together into something magical--something that would make this film worth while. But, unfortunately, it just never came. The sum of all the good parts just couldn't outweigh a story that seems like it should have seen at least one more re-write.

As the story begins, we watch a woman setting up the dining room table, as though for a celebration. She has been cooking up for a dinner, but we do not know what is the occasion. Something peculiar, we never see the woman's face, just her activities around the kitchen and dining area. When the man delivering packages of meat does not get any answer at the apartment's door, his alternative is to bring them to Jose's place, across the street. Jose Kurtz turns out to be the former husband of Nora, the woman we saw earlier.When Jose goes to Nora's place, he is shocked to find her dead. It is clear to him she committed suicide. Jose being Jewish must contact the rabbi in order to set the funeral arrangement. The rabbi objects to Nora being buried in sacred ground, upsetting Jose. Having to deal with the problem, he decides to go to a local funeral place where he contracts for the necessary details to have her buried in a regular cemetery. "Nora's Will" directed by Mariana Chenillo, is a dramatic Mexican comedy that explores the clash between traditional Jewish culture and that of the country in which the story is set. In flashbacks we get to know what happened between Jose and Nora and what caused their divorce. The fact that Jose has only moved across the street from his former wife, speaks volumes. While he is not openly grieving, memories of a happier time in his marriage comes rushing to his mind. Fernando Lujan playing Jose makes an impression. He is stoic facing the final preparations for a wife he stop living with a long time ago, but in reality he has not stopped loving her. An in a way, finding the binoculars used by Nora to spy on Jose, also indicates she has not completely forgotten of the man she fell in love.Ms. Chenillo's debut shows a new talent in the Mexican cinema.

A lethargic beginning is never really overcome in this very slight, mildly interesting and amusing film. Complications from the death of the eponymous title character eventually provide some conflict but the main tension for too low is between the ex-husband and his memory of the controlling woman he left 20 years ago, only to move next door, ostensibly to keep an eye on his son. Never bad and not poorly paced for its slight content, the main problem is a concept that just isn't developed enough. The story as presented here could've made a strong short film but is ultimately meager at feature length, despite a few twists and fine acting.

This is, without a doubt, one of the best examples of what talented Mexican filmmakers can achieve. Excellent plot, impeccable script, outstanding actors and an amazing director's work. No big sound effects or different locations are needed to tell a deep story that leaves you wanting to know more (Ms. Chenillo, please tell us there will be another film about Jose's life!), as a matter of fact, it takes place inside an apartment in Mexico City, for the most part. Certain aspects of Jewish beliefs and traditions that many viewers would not understand are seamlessly integrated in the dialogs, and yet there's no saturation, no "over explaining". It's a very clean story, almost unadorned, and yet there is so much beneath it! As a viewer, you never lose interest, on the contrary, you get more and more intrigued as the story unveils -flashbacks are a smart element that adds to the anticipation. A thought lingers on after the movie ends: humans beings, regardless of faith or heritage, are rich, complicated and fascinating beyond the limits of life. Standing ovation!!!