Simply A Masterpiece

Although it has its amusing moments, in eneral the plot does not convince.

Fun premise, good actors, bad writing. This film seemed to have potential at the beginning but it quickly devolves into a trite action film. Ultimately it's very boring.

The movie's neither hopeful in contrived ways, nor hopeless in different contrived ways. Somehow it manages to be wonderful

Just another run-of-the-mill,Hallmark-like,tear-jerker Xmas movie.It's set up so syrup-like, especially the music, that it had me looking at my watch. (not a good sign). You know exactly how it's gonna end way before the ending and that to me just doesn't make for good movie watching experience.This would have been a great half hour episode of some Christmas show But you can't really get all the dynamics of the storyline in that time frame either.Everyone involved especially the main stars, Ann Jillian, Robert Hays, Ashley Gorrell and the late great Jack Palance were good.I definitely could see the beautiful Ann Jillian as the mayor and vet of the small Mayberry-like town and the always reliable Robert Hays as a surgeon who has lost his confidence and courage in himself and comes back to this his hometown and try to find himself, The young Ashley Gorrell did OK as his daughter and the wonderful late Jack Palance as grandpa Bob was a special treat.I did not care for the falseness of the towns people who because they need a doctor, act like they so much care for the Hays character so he will stay on. I just feel the hypocrisy of the people and they act like that because of what they want. If they didn't need Hays, they would have care less he was back in town type of deal. All fake for me. All in all not a bad film but for me a one time viewing only type of deal. So , get a box of Kleenex and warm up the hot chocolate and marshmallows, and see it for yourself.

this movie is so good to see. i saw it last week with my dad and i wanted my mom to see it as well. i want to buy it for Christmas even! it made me cry because of the great acting cast and storyline as well as the script. this movie feels like home to me and i love the way it is filmed in Toronto, Canada but set in Iowa, USA. i love the snow scenes. everybody did a terrific job on this movie and i congratulate them all. i wish it was shown every year in December and made a big deal of like other Christmas movies are, like "The Santa Clause". somehow this movie made me to want to keep watching, even though i knew it would entail a happy ending. i like movies with happy endings. this movie is so cool and i recommend it to every family out there who believe in the spirit of Christmas.

This is a great movie.(I would rate this as one of my all time favorite movies) I usually cannot watch movies a second time but this is one movie I can watch over and over. Ashley Gorrell is awesome in this movie and the cast all seem to click together. This is a movie everyone can enjoy. You will need a box of Kleenex when watching this movie. Ann Jillian, Jack Palance, Robert Hays, Ashley Gorrell are great together. I would love to see a sequel to this movie You won't regret purchasing or renting this movie. I'll Be Home For Christmas is a must see every year at the holidays and gets one ready for the holidays. It puts Christmas in perspective and makes you realize how important family, friends and community are. A+

I adore this movie. It very much reminds me of excellent Hollywood movies from the 1940s - and should probably have been released in theaters.There are a number of very interesting conflicts in this movie - the appeal of small towns vs. big cities, the psychological conflict within the male protagonist regarding his competence and career, the efforts by small Midwestern towns to remain viable, the awakening of the female middle aged protagonist to her own loneliness - and her subsequent defeated effort to resolve it, the granddaughter's past minimal relationship to her rural grandfather.So many of the issues in this movie ring true - especially for those in the Midwest but not exclusively.So many small towns have faded as the young and ambitious left the town far behind them when they went away to college - schools, hospitals, department stores, are shut down as the dwindling population no longer requires - or can support - them.Similarly, the burn-out of an upper middle class professional after two decades of practice - and without a spouse to sustain him -- is true in countless cases.Finally, the unlikelihood that a single woman doctor (in this case a veterinarian) will fall for someone of similar interests and education -when she returns to the small town after many years away at college and veterinary school, is very true.The acting by all the principals is wonderful - Ann Jillian is graciously lovely, vulnerable and far more understated than in most roles I've seen her in, Robert Hays is his very credible gentlemanly self, Jack Palance is extraordinary - again far more understated than I've seen him in other roles, and the actress playing the girl plays her part so well - her trepidation, enthusiasm, directness, warmth.One thing that I particularly liked about this movie was the pairing of Ann Jillian and Robert Hays. They're two actors I'd never have thought of together - the former has played such brassy and showy roles in so many productions and the latter is so self-effacing, almost shy. Yet this fits their parts perfectly - you can see in their looks and intelligence why they'd have been drawn together in high school - and yet not wanted to continue the relationship when both went off to college.In the very different personalities of the actor and actress, you feel they're perfect as a FORMER high school couple. And yet as the decades have passed, one can readily accept the growing vulnerability of Ann Jillian's character - one can readily see how the vet's once spectacular attention-getting looks have (gently) faded as she's lived her life of activity and entrepreneurship, taken charge of necessary things - and taken little note of her own self. In this sense, the (still beautiful) Ann Jillian's current round figure and her character's dowdy camouflaging clothes perfectly fit the self-heedlessness of her character.Similarly, the lines (on which the camera focuses) upon the face of the still boyish looking Hays character are testament to the loss of confidence suffered in the years since the death of the once brilliant funny wife who had fortified his own sense of being successful. His wife no longer shields his lack of confidence. Hays looks careworn and doubtful - and few of his body movements, even the way he looks at others, are committed.In their current situations, these characters' emotions, hesitations, decisions - even their lies - are very well-written and very credible because they're wonderfully portrayed.The small town is well-portrayed (especially the speed with which news told to one is passed around), and not overly sentimentalized. Moreover, the big city (Minneapolis? St. Paul? Rochester Minn.?) is - surprisingly and wonderfully - NOT made to look bad to make the small town look appealing. The availability of fun ice rinks, great shopping, a well-run major hospital - ARE advantages of the big city - and they're not downplayed in the interest of the story.These are real adults - and this is a wonderfully adult movie. If you liked movies with say, Barbara Stanwyck or Bette Davis, Katherine Hepburn or Irene Dunne - this movie's for you. It evokes truly strong emotions in the viewer because it all feels so very true.I hope this becomes one of those movies that steadily gains enormous favor over time - and becomes ritual viewing across the country.It's that good.