Self-important, over-dramatic, uninspired.
... View MoreIt's no definitive masterpiece but it's damn close.
... View MoreBlending excellent reporting and strong storytelling, this is a disturbing film truly stranger than fiction
... View MoreIf you're interested in the topic at hand, you should just watch it and judge yourself because the reviews have gone very biased by people that didn't even watch it and just hate (or love) the creator. I liked it, it was well written, narrated, and directed and it was about a topic that interests me.
... View MoreThere are many reviews on here that are ridiculous and simply based in idiocrasy! There are actually people docking the documentary because it films a U.S. vigilante/border patrol guy from an observational perspective, who these reviewers disagree with, therefore they dock this documentary for it, whereas otherwise they claim to have enjoyed it. It just so happens that I disagree with the guy as well (or at the very least recognize what the dude is doing accomplishes nothing). This documentary does nothing to persuade the viewer to the vigilante border guy's view, rather it observes the guy telling his story. Then you get to see for yourself what this guy is doing based on his actual actions (no bias propaganda). Actually, every action that we watch the guy carry out is of him stopping some poor scared people trying to get over the border. At no point does it attempt to convince us that these scared people are cartel members or that he should be stopping these people. If anything one is more likely to disagree with the guy after seeing what he is doing for yourself. These people who are disgruntled over the observation of someone they disagree with genuinely have a serious mental disorder. Whether you agree or disagree with the guy, it's interesting to hear what his perspective is and watch exactly what he is doing. Rather than taking his or someone else's word for it. The guy convinces himself that he is doing something against the cartels even though there is nothing we see to support the guys claim... so why can't these nutball reviewers differentiate? It's simple, they have a mental disorder. Anyways, that wasn't the theme of the documentary, it's vigilantism. Two different kinds of vigilantism, but they both correlate in that they are people taking it upon themselves to act in areas where the government refuses too. However the story over the Mexican border is where this documentary excels. You should understand after seeing this, Government/Cartels are in bed together if not one of the same thing. This applies to everywhere in the world. A different word for it is used everywhere, in Mexico they're called cartels. So yes, I think this documentary captured a bunch of amazing stuff and tried to come up with a way to work both stories into the documentary. As a result, should I rate this doc a 6 or a 7 because both stories felt loosely tied to me, even though it captures what was and is going on in Mexico (and everywhere in the world I believe) unlike anything ever has before and both stories are very entertaining. In my opinion, this is the best reference that I have ever seen demonstrated before as to a pattern that continues to go on, over and over and over again throughout history. In Mexico you have the Cartels, In Russia you have the KGB, in the US we've had a bunch of ravenous groups over the years in which the government pretends to be against, but at the end of the day they do absolutely nothing to stop them and come to find out they are in bed together. So, surprise people the government (gov. is just a generic expression, but you could say the state, the CIA or the powers that be which control gov.), are the real manufacturers of these drugs (there are several instances over the years where this has been declassified information (particularly the CIA). Even though we see in this documentary, the newly united government are the ones out making the drugs (so whether the state/gov are the actual manufacturers, they are always at the very least the ghost manufacturers and get paid/kickbacks the same either way) and these horrendous gangs/cartels are the ones selling their product. This documentary demonstrates the Mexican government/military does nothing to stop the cartels and in fact come to the cartels aid. Then they show what happens to the liberation groups that wake up and fight back, they eventually get infiltrated/ convinced/paid off by the government to step aside and/or join forces and then you're right back to square one. Like that Papa Smurf clown. I'm curious if the guy was an infiltrator from the start or if he was bought off. One thing for certain is; he allowed some audience members running some cointelpro tactics to overpower him in a speech. In that instance, I believe they essentially had a handful or more of rehearsed and planned criticisms to bounces off one another in tandem, which can easily and effectively bring an entire audience who would otherwise be in support of the speakers cause, against the speaker and the cause. This stuff is taught in CIA/FBI training and I'm sure in many other gov organizations around the world. Another way is just through media control and what not, they convince the people through propaganda or whatever the "horrible" things that the people/liberation group are doing. In this instance, I feel certain that the crowd criticism was a planned cointelpro tactic 100% without any shadow of a doubt. Anyways, this information has been known by some people for years, but this is probably the first time that I've ever seen someone in the thick of it actually capturing it on film as it was happening they actually captured the entire process from start to finish It's amazing! This documentary (the Mexico part) is an essential demonstration of something that people really need to be aware of.
... View MoreWhile the war on drugs in Mexico may seem simple at first glance, with an obvious good and bad, "Cartel Land" has shown me that it's much, much more complicated.The film is both a character study of Jose Mireles and Tim Foley, and a tense examination of why they are currently stuck in this awful position. The film begins by showing Mireles beginning his resistance, or the Autodefensas. From the first scene, it is clear who the bad guys are, the cartels, and who the good guys are, the Autodefensas. We begin to be shown, and told about, the horrible acts of the cartels, and the autodefensas' fight to free the innocent towns from the hands of these tyrants. On the other side of the border we have Tim Foley, a man fighting for a similar cause on a much smaller scale. He recognizes the enemy, the cartels, and wants to keep them away.What we slowly come to realize, is that the Auto defenses are not as morally sound as we thought they were. After Mireles barely survives a plane crash that was possibly intentional, "Papa Smurf" is put in charge. Under his control, we begin to see more complaints from innocent citizens than the rejoicing that we saw earlier in the film. There are many other red flags, when we see them capture a man who was shooting at them, and then hear them torturing one. There is a moment when one of the Autodefensas says "you cut off one of our fingers, we cut off five of yours", and this is when I realized that they w were slowly becoming corrupt. When we hear that there is a cartel within the autodefensas, and that the government will forgive them for everything if they join, all hope is lost. What was once started to end the cycle has only become another cog in the machine, and it's terrifying to see this transition. Even Mireles, a man who seemed to be a great leader and a family man had turned to adultery for some comfort in this hopeless situation he has gotten himself into. The final scene of the film uses the same shots as the first, and the same dialogue from the same people. But what was once the obvious bad guy is suddenly revealed to be part of the police force in Mexico. So, is there any hope, or are we doomed to perpetuate the cycle eternally? Tom states the outsiders perspective. If we realize our mistakes and do the opposite we can stop this. But on the inside, we witness an anti-cartel vigilante organization, transform into a government run cartel organization, almost without us even realizing.
... View MoreThis is the most real and most different perspective I have seen in this doco subject. It is an eye opening, jaw dropping, heart aching ride that will more than likely leave you feeling like you have lost all hope in humanity but in my opinion if a film can draw out emotion and make you think too it has done a good job. The doco gives different points of view but mainly it is divided into two alternating perspectives. One perspective is from the Mexican side and one from the U.S.A side which, without giving too much away, kept me very interested all the way through.If your after a feel good ending with butterflies and fairy floss then you might want to reconsider watching this doco. This is a must watch for any person who has some type of fascination or interest in this topic.
... View MoreI like a good documentary specially if it has more than one points of view in the same argument. You see the U.S. civilian border patrol and the Mexicans self defense unit against a common enemy, and how both even if there non related in anyway see eye to eye in that situation. The civilian border patrol in Arizona stopping drug and human trafficking, as both these affect there situation back home. Im not particularly fond of the idea these people have on illegal Mexicans as they look at them as scum, but one has to understand the why and they are trying to change the situation for there family's. The Selfdefence unit created by civilians in Mexico out of necessity to protect themselves from the cartels because the police and the military don't help much and more than half are corrupted, leaving them no other choice. Again i do not agree with this method but when your government gives you their back a few choices are left. In the end personally i have to agree and disagree with what i think is right and to understand the people that are involved and their determination to help their own, i recommend this but have an open mind and try to place yourself in that situation.
... View More