Such a frustrating disappointment

Save your money for something good and enjoyable

Perfect cast and a good story

Good idea lost in the noise

I watched the American print of this movie, where inexplicably the title was changed to ATLAS IN THE LAND OF THE CYCLOPS - despite the fact that the hero's name is clearly Maciste in the film, and Atlas doesn't come into it! Also, somewhat amusingly, the credits list Mitchell Gordon as the main star instead of Gordon Mitchell. Those crazy Americans! These oddities aside, whatever the title, MACISTE IN THE LAND OF THE CYCLOPS is a example of the peplum genre at its monster-slaying, boulder-throwing finest! Packed with incredible feats of strength and action throughout, plus a mythical creature for Maciste to battle at the end, this would be a brilliant film if it wasn't for a few pacing problems in the second half, where nearly nothing happens for around half an hour. As it stands, it's still a very good and highly recommended film which all fantasy lovers should seek out.The rugged and dependable peplum stalwart Gordon Mitchell (The Giant of Metropolis) leads the way as strongman Maciste here, and he looks like he's having a great time. Mitchell is given lots of material to work with and is hardly ever given time to stand still - he's just too busy righting wrongs or fighting evil! This gives the film a frenetic pacing which makes it more than watchable and also makes the time fly by. The supporting cast of Italian actors and actresses are fairly undistinguished, although it's interesting to see fellow American black bodybuilder Paul Wynter as another strongman, this time on the opposite side (and yes, they do fight). One exception is the actor playing the baby in the film - it's none other than Fabio, apparently a quite respected male model these days. What a way to start a career! Director Antonio Leonviola (just credited as "Leonviola" in the American release) is no Mario Bava, or even Riccardo Freda, but all scenes are well-shot and competently handled. The skillful editing also hides the low budget of the film, thus by splicing frames of a model ship quickly with images of people supposedly inside a ship (although you never actually see them above deck from a distance) you get a realistic effect. The plot is simple but packed with incident, as is the way with the best of the genre like MACISTE AGAINST THE VAMPIRE.As an aside, the Cyclops himself is pretty good, thanks to a neat makeup job which gives him the solitary eye and some snappy editing which makes him look three times the size of the not-inconsiderable Mitchell. At the end of the film, they have a titanic battle, Maciste blinds him with a sword (ouch) before pulling off his final trick, causing a cave-in. Ta-da! Everybody is saved, the evil have been punished and Maciste lives to fight another day. The end. One other thing: we learn that apparently the name "Maciste" means "made of rock", an apt description if ever I heard one for Mitchell's granite-hewn, super-human muscleman. As you may have already guessed, I give this film the thumbs-up!

Strange «péplum», a bit on the sadistic side, made me feel terrible for the poor Cyclops, who is described as a captive freak, unlike the busy and aggressive creatures Ray Harryhausen created for «The 7th Voyage of Sinbad». For the proceeding, maestro Mario Serandrei's editing is rather lazy, especially in the action scenes, where the tempo of the cutting is not particularly inspired, and the shots linger on Gordon Mitchell's muscles. Even Chelo Alonso goes through a strange routine, from evil queen to woman in love, excluding the possibility of one of her sensual dance scenes; and Mitchell is one very strange looking fellow, with a gentle personality that seems at odds with his character, supposedly a lonely highlander. But «Maciste in the Land of the Cyclops» has ladies in distress chewing gum, «menacing» lions that resemble rugs, a villain (funny Dante DiPaolo) who is always smiling when he's saying his meanest dialog lines, and lights that follow the characters through kitsch settings and barren exteriors. So don't let it pass you: it has a lot to enjoy. Watch it!

In Atlas in the Land of the Cyclops, our hero Maciste (Maciste, Atlas, Samson, Hercules - what's in a name?) must safeguard the life of a young prince whose father has been killed by the evil Queen Capys. The Queen wants the child so that she can break a centuries old curse by handing the baby over to the Cyclops she keeps chained in a pit. At first she attempts to use her womanly ways on Maciste, but to no avail. And as predictable as the sun following the night, the Queen ends up falling for Maciste. But there are others in the Queen's court who still seek the child and an end to the curse. Can Maciste rescue the baby and defeat the Cyclops before it's too late? Atlas in the Land of the Cyclops is what I'll call an above average example of the peplums or sword and sandal movies being pumped-out of Italy from the late 1950s to the mid 1960s. Gordon Mitchell is on hand to provide the beef of the title role. He may not have been as big as Steve Reeves (who all Italian movie muscle men must necessarily be compared) or some of the others, but he's got a winning smile and a definite athleticism about him. Chelo Alonso as Queen Capys is a real beauty and quite good in her role. In fact, the whole cast is quite nice. The Cyclops is very well done and another example of the fine, creative work being done before the advent of CGI - even by low-budget Italian filmmakers. Lots of good fight scenes, very few long drawn-out dialogue filled moments, and plenty of guys running around with those scrub-brush looking helmets - what's not to love. I guess my biggest complaints are with the dubbing and the state of available DVD transfers. The dubbing is incredibly stilted. In a few scenes, Mitchell sounds a bit like Tonto from the old Lone Ranger series. As for the available transfers, I can only assume that my enjoyment of Atlas in the Land of the Cyclops would have been enhanced had it not seemed I was watching the movie through dirty dishwater. Even with these negatives, and I realize I may be overstating things a bit here, I'll go ahead and give it a 7/10 and recommend it to fans of peplums.

If viewers can get by the crummy existing home video transfers currently available ATLAS IN THE LAND OF THE CYCLOPS, as this is know in it's English language form, is actually a superior example of the Italian Peplum sword & sandal genre. The problem with the existing versions isn't with the film, it's that a glorious widescreen (2:35:1 Techniscope) popcorn movie has been cropped and pan/scanned down to an abysmal, color rotted 16mm fullscreen reduction print meant for television distribution back in the 1960s. There should be a Crimes Against Humanity tribunal charged with tracking down those responsible for ruining this and countless other movies like it, perhaps forcing them to watch endlessly looped repeats of those old SnackMaster infomercials as punishment. The original elements are probably long lost and like a butchered scrap of an old Michelangelo painting, this is all we have left. It's a horrible loss.But even in such a miserable state this is quite the little Hercules/Samson/Maciste style adventure, with big grinning Gordon Mitchell at his finest as another he-man wandering the ancient world and righting wrongs. This production actually had a decent budget for it's time as well, with a huge cast of extras and some genuinely clever effects sequences and strong man spectacle moments -- at one point Mitchell even rows an entire slave galley at ramming speed, by himself -- along with the requisite eye candy Veil Dance naval gazing for the dads, slave mistreatment scenes, lots of Pizza Pizza guards running around in plumed helmets, the ubiquitous moment where the hero gets to flirt with all the serving girls or share wine & grapes with the evil sexy queen who is responsible for the misdeeds that he must set to rights.What makes this one stand out is that all of that happens before Atlas, as he is called here, even squares off against a genuinely frightful looking 18 foot tall Cyclops down in it's pit for a duel to the death to save both the pretty princess and the rightful infant heir to the throne. The Cyclops rulez and for once the muscle bound hero is presented with a monster that's quite worthy of his talents. Their battle is a doozie and actually somewhat graphic for it's time. You'd really have to be a cold heartless bastard not to get a kick out of it, and as usual the clever way it was filmed puts any CGI rendered special effects sequence depicting similar events to shame.And as usual the big lummox of a hero rides off into the sunset at the end while the adoring crowds cheer his heroism & derring-do, something that quite frankly the world could use a bit more of these days. I'd encourage anyone with a love for fantasy adventure/action films to seek this baby out, and you can: It's available on one of those 50 Movie Packs called "The Warriors Collection" easily found on Amazon.com for a few dollars, featuring forty nine other movies more or less just like it, which would take you about two weeks of non-stop viewing to get through it. And people say getting snowed in sucks, I call it an opportunity for cheesy Euro man-beef fantasy indulgence with an exceptionally cool monster to boot. Ignore the crummy picture quality, pop a bucket of popcorn and enjoy!8/10