Self-important, over-dramatic, uninspired.

This movie feels like it was made purely to piss off people who want good shows

Great story, amazing characters, superb action, enthralling cinematography. Yes, this is something I am glad I spent money on.

Great example of an old-fashioned, pure-at-heart escapist event movie that doesn't pretend to be anything that it's not and has boat loads of fun being its own ludicrous self.

It amazes me when I start to read the reviews of some of these Walt Disney shorts where the comments obviously took longer to write than watching the actual cartoon. I guess that's a tribute to the wonderful work the studio put out during it's early years. This one features Mickey Mouse, Donald Duck and Goofy, with Mickey taking a bit of a back seat allowing his co-stars to do the heavy lifting. Donald fends off hungry seagulls as a pelican grabs his lunch, while Goofy finds himself on the wrong end of a harpoon cannon. Upended on a rope suspended over a sleepy whale, he eventually finds himself looking for a way out as the whale gives chase to Donald and wrecks their ship! Through it all, Mickey remains silent with his own problems fending off a boomerang-ing pail of water. Funny how these cartoons manage to maintain a sense of timelessness about them. With perhaps minor updates, the picture looks as fresh as if it were made quite recently.

Not a classic by all means, but great fun regardless. Mickey doesn't feature that much here, but Goofy and Donald have plenty to do and as pretty much always are peerless. The animation is done in a very nice fluid and colourful visual style, and the music is rousing and clever. Also prevalent are some interesting sight gags, and the whale is a great point of interest. When it comes to cartoon whales I prefer Willie from Willie the Operatic Whale and Spot from the Little Mermaid series, but this whale is memorable. The story is simple and a tad predictable but only occasionally, but it is effective mostly. The voice acting is well done, with Clarence Nash coming off best.Overall, nicely done and entertaining. 9/10 Bethany Cox

I am somewhat confused that this one is classified as one of the "Mickey Cartoons". Sure, Mickey Mouse is in it, but he doesn't really do anything here and he barely speaks something here. Plus, the story focus more on Goofy, Donald Duck and a whale than Mickey Mouse.It's a generally enjoyable cartoon. The only thing I have to criticize is that they want to hunt the whale. But that doesn't happen. Fortunately, it turns out to be a comical story, especially the bits inside the gigantic whale and the bit when the whale destroys the boat.I love that whale. The whale is the main interest in this story. Without the whale, this would have been probably nothing special.Although quite old-fashioned, for something that is from the year 1938, it doesn't look as dated as it could be (except for some minor clues, such as the older appearance of Goofy and Mickey Mouse).

Mickey, Donald and Goofy are whale hunters? How disgusting! But this was made back when Disney was non-PC. Which is really how it should have stayed if you don't mind me contradicting myself.Obviously, because of their clumsiness, they aren't actually going to kill any whale and you can bet your bottom dollar that their whaling ship ain't gonna be afloat by the end.In the usual hijinks Donald is tormented as seagulls eat his sandwiches and Goofy can't fire a harpoon to save himself (am I the only one who saw pretty strong phallic imagery with that cannon?) and Mickey does...nothing. Why is this even categorised as a Mickey cartoon? The bit inside the whale is cute, the rest never rises above adequacy.