People are voting emotionally.

Expected more

While it doesn't offer any answers, it both thrills and makes you think.

The movie really just wants to entertain people.

"The Magic of Lassie" proves that you cannot teach Hollywood new tricks about an old dog. The famous collie, who has more sense than most humans, sets out to protect defenseless animals and return to her masters when she is unjustly taken away from them. "Lassie" movies and television shows are, of course, strictly formula entertainment. The plot and dogs are the same, with minor variations, only the human change. Indeed, this "Lassie" flopped so badly at the box office that James Stewart retired from acting and fans would have to wait until 1994 when "Cocoon: The Return" director Daniel Petrie made the new "Lassie" movie with Helen Slater of "Supergirl" fame. Since then a short-lived "Lassie" television series aired between 1989 and 1991, and director Charles Sturridge helmed "Lassie" with Peter O'Toole and Samantha Morton in 2005. "The Magic of Lassie" script by Jean Holloway of "Till the Clouds Roll By" from a story by Robert & Richard Sherman duplicates for the most part the classic story of "Forbidden Planet" director Fred M. Wilcox's "Lassie Come Home" with Roddy McDowall and Elizabeth Taylor, the first movie about "Lassie." Unquestionably, this "Lassie" entertains, but it lacks the pathos of the original as much as the production values.This time around Lassie belongs to grandpa Clovis (James Stewart of "It's A Wonderful Life") who owns the Mitchell Winery in Northern California. Clovis' young grandson, Chris (Michael Sharrett of "Deadly Friend") and teenage granddaughter, Kelly (Stephanie Zimbalist of TV's "Remington Steele") live with him now because their parents are dead. The conflict begins when nasty old Jamison (Pernell Roberts of TV's "Trapper John"), a millionaire too rich and greedy for his own good, tries to buy up Clovis' property. Naturally, Clovis refuses to sell out. Before Jamison leaves, he crosses paths with Lassie and man's best friend growls at him. Ironically, it turns out that Lassie really belongs to Jamison. Jamison owned Lassie's mom, and Lassie was his pet puppy. Somehow, Jamison lost Lassie and Clovis adopted the compassionate collie for his Chris. Anyway, Jamison claims ownership and Clovis has no alternative but to return Lassie to the villainous tycoon. Indeed, the dastardly Jamison wants to change Lassie's name to Heatherbelle. Lassie, however, refuses to be a part of Jamison's plans and escapes from Jamison's Colorado mansion."The Magic of Lassie" becomes a series of journeys for our eponymous pup. Chiefly, Lassie sets out to return to Clovis and Chris. Clovis' grandson complicates matters when he runs away to Colorado to find Lassie. Not surprisingly, Clovis resolves to track down both Lassie as well as Chris. At fade-out, the Mitchells are reunited with everybody's favorite collie. "The Magic of Lassie" builds up a full head of steam, but squanders its momentum at fade-out. The pacing of the action is anemic and uneven. Holloway is largely to blame for these faults. It looks as if half-way through the filmmakers decided to change the focus of the plot. Everything turns on Lassie and her struggle to get home. The potential action of a clash between Clovis and Jamison over the former's vineyards and Lassie's role in that could have been more rewarding.Credit must be given to "One Million Years B.C." director Don Chaffey for his very competent direction. The action moves swift and is pleasantly predictable. Among the film's few virtues is "Dirty Mary, Crazy Larry" lenser Michael Margulies' photography and camera-work as well as the rugged Utah scenery. The cast, including cameos by seasoned thespians Mickey Rooney, Alice Faye, Mike Mazurki, Gene Evans as well as the Mike Curb Congregation and Pat & Debbie Boone, is solid. Several musical interludes concisely highlight the film's themes without calling undue attention to them. Although it is far from being Oscar winning material, the G-rated "Magic of Lassie" provides ideal entertainment for children and grown-ups will invariably find it a refreshing change from the usual sex and violence in most films. Interestingly, the song "When You're Loved" received an Academy Award nomination for Best Song.

The Magic of Lassie was the beloved collie's last appearance on the big screen. Lassie was quite the box office draw in her day, but according to the box office the day had passed.Not that the film is all that bad. Maybe if the Sherman songwriting team who gave us so many things for Walt Disney back in their day had produced something like what they did for Mary Poppins, The Magic of Lassie might be better remembered. But nothing like Chim Chim Cheree or Supercalifragilisticexpialidocious comes from this score.James Stewart is raising a pair of grandchildren, Stephanie Zimbalist and Michael Sharrett. He's got an acquisitive neighbor in Pernell Roberts who wants to buy his land and Stewart won't sell. On that trip he spots Lassie and thinks Lassie might have been his dog who survived a fire in the kennel as a pup some years ago.Roberts proves his case and Stewart reluctantly hands over the dog, but that doesn't sit well with young Sharrett or Lassie and they take off going a third of the country in different directions searching for each other.Lassie and Sharrett run into all kinds of interesting people. From Lassie's point of view the film starts to look like a big screen version of the Canadian show, The Littlest Hobo. Sharrett proves to be a plucky lad, but he gets himself in a heap of trouble.Of course this being a kid's film you know we're going to see a happy ending. Let's just say that in Lane Davies, a young lawyer who has eyes for Zimbalist, he proves handy to have around.The Magic of Lassie marked Alice Faye's farewell screen appearance and it was also James Stewart's last starring feature film release as well. I was disappointed they did not share the screen. Mickey Rooney and Mike Mazurki as a wrestler and his trainer have a couple of laughs themselves.Still though The Magic of Lassie did not do sufficient box office to interest anyone in any more films so far about the old collie.

If you love catchy, melodic songs (a couple of which could have been hits!), you will love this movie. The endearing performances of Jimmy Stewart and Mickey Rooney, both of whom sing, also make this a must-see for their fans.The story and script is just OK otherwise, standard boy-and-his-dog adventure. It's a shame that the soundtrack album has not been released on CD. I bought the LP on a whim, having not seen the film, and was struck by the high quality of the songwriting and performances. Highlights are "When You're Loved", sung by Debby Boone, which should have been a hit, "That Hometown Feeling" sung by Stewart (quite well for a non-singer), "Travelin' Music" sung by Rooney, and "Banjo Song" by the Mike Curb Congregation in one of their last recorded appearances.

This is basically a revamp of Lassie Come Home. James Stewart is forced into giving up the family pet when a sly neighbour says she belongs to him. He takes the dog from California all the way to Colorado but naturally she escapes and makes her way home, just as Stewart's grandson runs away to find her. It's all one big cross country adventure that just doesn't come off as well as LCH. The young boy is annoying, the songs are awful, and Mickey Rooney's cameo with a wrestler friend is just downright strange. But, James Stewart is a treat as usual, really the perfect grandfather. 7/10