It’s fine. It's literally the definition of a fine movie. You’ve seen it before, you know every beat and outcome before the characters even do. Only question is how much escapism you’re looking for.

The story, direction, characters, and writing/dialogue is akin to taking a tranquilizer shot to the neck, but everything else was so well done.

The movie's neither hopeful in contrived ways, nor hopeless in different contrived ways. Somehow it manages to be wonderful

The thing I enjoyed most about the film is the fact that it doesn't shy away from being a super-sized-cliche;

I HAVE WATCHED THIS MOVIE MORE THAN 100 TIMES. This is my most favourite romantic movie ever. It is a very beautiful movie, with solid acting shown by madhvan (maddy) , dia mirza and saif ali khan. The dialogue are so well written. the best thing of movie is it's songs, they are really heart touching, and it's background music also. and the rivalry of saif ad maddy is damn amazing. some pure comedy scenes are also included in the movies ,which are really funny (by maddy's friends). great supporting acting is there by anupam kher also.overall it is a must watch movie for bollywood movie lovers.

First of all, I'm not sure how this movie has a 7.5 IMDb rating. But, anyway. So the movie revolves around a strange love triangle between Madhavan (Maddy) , Saif Ali Khan, (Rajiv) and Dia Mirza (Reena). This movie is a good example of how the audience's logic is sometimes taken for granted.The Good: 1. The music. If the music wasn't good, the movie would have been a total letdown. Zara Zara and Dil Ko are the best songs in my opinion, and the background music is pleasant too. 2. The first half of the movie is still somewhat entertaining, especially the sequences between Maddy and his friends trying to track down Reena, and the scene in the grocery store was quite funny too.The Bad: 1. Saif Ali Khan - probably his most annoying performance. He looks like a wimp and overacts his way through the whole film and what the hell are his outfits? Oh, and in one of the songs he decides to roam the streets shirtless. Charming, isn't it? 2. Dia Mirza's character is presented as too innocent and rather dim-witted. Why didn't she get her phone re-connected? And why does she get so angry at Maddy when she was in love with him too? 3. Everyone overacted in the second half, and Maddy's violence seems over the top. The last 30 minutes of the movie were a drag.

Friends this this one of the best love story that have ever made,i watched this movie for more than 50 times and still want to watch it.Madhvan did great acting as well as Diya is looking so cute.Songs are still heart touching.This is the movie which i first saw when i was in class 7th my love story too started at this very age and i was madly in love with that girl.This story have song's which will touch your heart if you are in love.This movie also has record for the most movie title songs. This movie is made in so many languages and all over South India it was super hit and i felt so disappointed to know it was flop in north India people in north still want masala movie but this is full package.

I watched that movie with a lot of hope after seeing its mark. I have been hugely disappointed. India is a country where girls are subject to an increasing level of sexual harassment. It is also a country where their honour is highly valued, and where a bad marriage often means a life of misery. This film portrays Reena as a nice girl, but a girl whose choice is never taken into account. I thought that the film would end by her choosing neither after she says she doesn't want to decide her future by closing her eyes. It would have been an excellent, and genuinely original ending. Sadly, she goes with her harasser (which is what Madhav is). This basically say you can lie to a girl, and you'll get her. It doesn't matter what she thinks, she'll fall for you. As in ALL Bollywood movies, the first half hour is about the guy creepily staring at her all the time. It doesn't take into account the fact that, yes we do realise that as girls. And we don't like it. No wonder guys in India think it's OK to stare at a girl and harass her. It's because of films like that such behaviour is tolerated. Then what happens? Oh yes, Madhav pursue her, threatens her, threaten to hit her friends, beat up a few guys, and tell her that he could have raped her. She cries, but so what? It works. The film ends when Rajiv 'gives her' (she doesn't even come on her own) to Madhav. I know the story between the guys was in the background, but come on. What does that say, really? Such a film deserves only blame. It normalises attitudes which are deeply disturbing in Indian society. Get a grip, and produce films that have the balls to actually portray women other than passive victims, and men as weirdos who stare, harass, and get what they want.