Good idea lost in the noise

Excellent characters with emotional depth. My wife, daughter and granddaughter all enjoyed it...and me, too! Very good movie! You won't be disappointed.

This is a small, humorous movie in some ways, but it has a huge heart. What a nice experience.

This film is so real. It treats its characters with so much care and sensitivity.

So OK, the plot of a Broadway producer who purposely makes flop shows so he doesn't have to pay his investors is quite familiar to every now. But this 1937 film comes 3 decades before Mel Brooks had a hit with this idea.This film stars Milton Berle in his first talkie feature film (yes he had been a boy actor in silent films) as a dope who gets stuck producing a show after crooked Jerome Cowan skips town. Berle doesn't know Cowan has swindled several people into backing the show. Harriet Hilliard (better known as Harriet Nelson) is to be the star of the show. There's also a guy (Joe Penner) trying to crash the show and an associate (Parkyakarkus) determined to keep him out.The film has several songs (Nelson and William Brady) and lots of comedy, with Penner and Parkyakarkus mangling the English language, and Berle (with Richard Lane) doing a long stock market skit. This is also the first showcase for Ann Miller (who was all of 14 years old).Others of note include Lorraine Krueger who dances and plays the girl friend, Patricia Wilder as the secretary, Dewey Robinson as one of the backers, starlets Frances Gifford and Hillary Brooke, Jan Duggan as an opera singer, and George Rosener as the doorman.The funniest bit may be the production number built around the jive dance called peckin' with Harriet Nelson as a peckin' bride.Of course both Harriet Nelson and Milton Berle would go on to become major television stars of the 1950s.

Harriet Hilliard looked a good bet for stardom. She was pretty and a lovely singer. In "Follow the Fleet" she proved she could emote. But she was obviously happier as a band singer and she married orchestra leader Ozzie Nelson.In a plot eerily similar to "The Producers" Lester Cowan plays Robert Hunt, a crooked producer, who finds it financially more rewarding only to put on flops. He then collects the profits and leaves the investors in the lurch. He explains it in the film.Jimmy (William Brady) and Pat (Harriet Hilliard) have a great idea - a show featuring new faces and fresh talent. With Pat's $15,000 inheritance they think the show will be great. Hunt is skipping town and leaves Milton Berle in charge (thinking that he will keep to the tried and true method - hiring only the talentless.) But Berle, who is also a backer and smitten with Pat, wants to put on a good show.There is a lot of talent. A man who impersonates a woman having a bath and Derry Deane, a Shirley Temple look-a-like who plays the violin. Lorraine Krueger is Suzy, a sparkling blonde who does a snappy tap dance routine during auditions - "It Goes to Your Feet".Beautiful Frances Gifford is introduced in the finale. Ann Miller is introduced as "our new dancing discovery" - boy could she dance - it was over all too soon. This film could have done with more of her and Lorraine Krueger and less of the "funny" men. At least in "Radio City Revels" (1938)(a companion film to this one with some of the same cast) Ann Miller had the female lead.Joe Penner's name doesn't mean anything to me - but I can remember a little bald guy named Egghead, who appeared in some cartoons and had a lot of the same expressions and mannerisms.For RKO Radio in the late 30s (not including the Astaire/Rogers films) this was a splashy musical.

This movie was fascinating to me because it is a time machine back to the childhoods of other people. My father and mother would have been 16 when this movie was a hit. I grew up hearing about Joe Penner from them as my father would regularly do the "Wanna buy a duck?" line (and, unbeknownst to me I'd hear Penner in cartoons without realizing it). You haven't lived until you heard my Tony Soprano-like father saying "You wanna buy a duck?" Believe me, you'd buy...or else! :) And then, of course, there is the premise of the movie, which a young (11 years old when this movie came out) Mel Brooks either knowingly or unknowingly ripped off in The Producers. Of course. "Springtime with Hitler in Germany" could only come out of the laughably perverted mind of Brooks. But still...My parents, Mel Brooks, and I wonder how many other people were influenced by these comedians...Milton Berle...the voice of Harriet of Ozzie and Harriet fame who was quite the singer in her day...I found myself laughing at Penner myself, and it was as if I were in a time warp sharing a laugh with my now long gone parents in their childhood. What a gift.

In this film, Jerome Cowan plays a seedy producer who would rather have flops than hits. Why? He sells more than 100% of the show to his investors. Does this plot sound familiar? This is the basic plot of Mel Brooks' classic "The Producers". However, this film was made 30 years earlier! Now "New Faces" is not nearly as funny or inventive as "The Producers". The plot is only there to hold together the various musical numbers, comedy sketches, and specialty acts which make up the film. By the middle of the film, Cowan has left his show in the hands of young Milton Berle, because Cowan's girlfriend is about to rat him out to his investors. Berle fixes the show."New Faces" is filled with 1930s comedians. Joe "Wanna Buy a Duck" Penner is top billed, but it is Milton Berle who really drives the film. Due to his caustic personality and "anything for a laugh" attitude, people tend to discount Berle's comedic abilities. He is truly funny in this film and it is his best cinema showcase until "Always Leave Then Laughing". Also on hand are Harry Einstein (Parkyakarkus)(the father of Albert Brooks and "Super Dave" Bob Einstein), and Bert "The Mad Russian" Gordon. Harriet Nelson, this time without Ozzie, is the leading lady. Teenage Ann Miller has a specialty number. The film also presents various '30s vaudeville performers doing their routines."New Faces" is not a great film, but it is certainly enjoyable. I wonder how many times Mel Brooks saw this film!