the audience applauded

This movie was so-so. It had it's moments, but wasn't the greatest.

The film may be flawed, but its message is not.

The film never slows down or bores, plunging from one harrowing sequence to the next.

It's a reunion for Ginger, With director Sam Wood ("Kitty Doyle", with Adolph Menjou ("Stage Door "). Then why is it such a fiasco? Ahead of its time? Perhaps, but that doesn't make it good. Out of the ordinary for Ginger Rogers' usual works? Definitely as well, because her character is like nails down a chalkboard, and not really likable. Ginger's other side of the track characters at least had some class and knew when to shut up. Another major issue is that she's about 15 years too old for this part, a young waif out of reform school becomes a professional pickpocket, trained by Basil Rathbone, and later taken in by the suave Menjou whose really out for no good as well. Along comes Jean Pierre Aumont to sweep her off her feet, and it's on the path to reform for the out of her element Ginger who wasn't having much success in films in the mid 1940's in spite of still being considered an A lister.This seems to be striving for the European style of films, not the Italian or French new wave, but an operatic elegance that was present in the films of Cocteau but seems forced and overstuffed here, ultimately seeming pretentious. Indeed, it is a remake of a French film. Ginger has one scene where she gets to screech like a teenager, making me wonder if dogs were barking in the San Fernando valley as she filmed this scene in Hollywood. She's forced to speak like a much younger character and dresses closer to how "I'll Be Seeing You" co-star Shirley Temple did. Menjou seems like he's still acting in the romantic comedies of the early 1930's, as if he was in another film altogether. This is pretty much an almost fiasco, but it looked so good in its lavishness that I just couldn't bear to give this a bomb. I give Ginger credit for wanting to try something different, but with all her talent and grace, she just wasn't right for this part.

HEARTBEAT is one of the most overt adult fairy tales that you'll come across, its storybook wedding at the end dropping any hint of realism. Such movies live or die by their charm or lack of such, and while I've little doubt that the French original was oozing with that quality, HEARTBEAT only sporadically compels a quiet smile on its audience's faces. Too much of it leaves us waiting for something to happen, and not much ever does.Ginger Rogers was certainly too old to play her character effectively (she was nearly twice Arlette's given age) and you can see her trying too hard to convey a girlish freshness and naivete with her performance (ironically, these are qualities that she specialized in during her dances with Fred Astaire). I originally thought Jean-Pierre Aumont's performance to be very dull, but a second viewing suggested that it was much more the writing than anything lacking in what Aumont was doing. Adolphe Menjou has little to do, and while Basil Rathbone brings energy and a sense of fun to proceedings that desperately needed these qualities, he disappears through the final 2/3 of the picture. A movie about his school for pickpockets would have been a lot easier to sit through than the plodding romance that we got.I was surprised to learn that HEARTBEAT, despite being a fairly high- budgeted project, earned a decent profit for RKO Studios. It's not terrible, but that's a bit more than it deserved.

When will they learn? That's purely rhetorical if anybody asks you. Born in 1917 - and still with us - Danielle Darrieux began her career in movies at the start of the Sound era and before the end of the thirties was the biggest female star on the French screen playing essentially the same role over and over in a series of lighter=than air romantic comedies that often required her to sing a song or two. In the mid-point of the decade she teamed up with writer-director Henri Decoin for The Green Domino, an entry with slightly more substance, they married and made a string (six) of successful souffles before divorcing in 1941 after Premiere Rendez- vous, but remained friends and made a further three films together. One of the biggest successes was Battement de coeur in which Darrieeux played a fugitive from Reform School who enrolled in a school for pickpockets under the leadership of Saturnin Fabre and, after a series of adventures encountered her Prince Charming in the shape of Claude Dauphin. It was delightful and enchanting in equal measure the perfect antidote to the outbreak of war. For reasons best known to themselves RKO decided to remake it in 1946 with a decidedly mid-thirtyish Ginger Rogers in the Darrieux role, Basil Rathbone replacing Saturnin Fabre and authentic, albeit wooden, Frenchman Jean-Pierre Aumont in the Claude Dauphin role. In a reverse alchemy a soufflé turned into a suet pudding and no one came out of it well. One to be avoided.

A light comedy like this is so different from typical Hollywood fare. It's a delightful French omelette - fluffy and sophisticated all at once. It leaves a sweet savour and refreshment, where other 'zany' comedies rely on just heaping up one cliché after another, thick and fast, with an often indigestible, overcooked, somewhat tiresome result."Heartbeat" keeps you guessing what will come next, like the most skilled flirt.Six years earlier in 1940, the film "Beat of the Heart" ("Battement de Coeur") was produced in France, starring the stunning Danielle Darrieux and the incredibly charismatic Claude Dauphin. As an American remake, "Heartbeat," according to the credits, was the creation of the three original French writers, plus two additional Hollywood writers for adaptation and additional dialogue.Overall, it makes its trans-cultural moves very well, in a romantic dance across the Atlantic.Ginger Rogers is completely convincing as an 18-year old, and on this point I disagree with other reviewers. It should be considered, for the sake of argument, that an 18-year old woman in Europe in 1940, or in 1946, had the maturing experience of World War II imprinted on her mind and heart. Truly, such a creature was a child-woman, not a plastic doll, an airhead, a sex object, or a narcissistic 'Material Girl'. She would have had the character of an adult, combined with true innocence, the innocence of a person who has seen cruelty and ugliness and crime, but has not yet personally become corrupted. As a matter of fact, I don't think any 18-year old American starlet would have had a clue as to how to play this part effectively. The following actresses certainly would have been "the right age". Amazingly, these five were the only American ingénues with star quality in 1946. Would you have cast any one of them, instead of Ginger Rogers? I doubt it. They simply weren't ready yet for such a role.Patricia Neal, age 20; Grace Kelly, age 17; Janet Leigh, age 19; Jeanne Crain, age 21; Ann Blyth, age 18.On the other hand, these two European lovelies would have been perfect, and they were already skilled on both stage and screen. But they would not come to Hollywood for several more years.Audrey Hepburn, age 17; Jean Simmons, age 17.Adding to its unique character, "Heartbeat" handles some very mature themes with a delicate, Cosmopolitan flare. The leading man is the lover of a married woman, and he is in the diplomatic corps of her older husband, "the Ambassador." This portrayal by Adolphe Menjou is perfect - suave, funny, devious, and attractive. Now Arlette knows from the very beginning that the handsome Jean-Pierre Aumont, the man she is falling in love with, the man who enjoys baiting her innocence, is himself a scoundrel. For his part, he tries to get rid of her puppy-dog affection by marrying her off to a sponger who will take her off his hands for a price. The actor captures this duplicity expertly. He is not at all a one-dimensional Romeo!By the way, the humorous sponger is played to the hilt by British comic actor Melville Cooper, who was actually a true hero, a veteran of the First World War who had been captured by the Germans. Another tour-de-force performance is delivered by Russian emigré Mikhail Rasumny. He was already 56 when he charmed the viewers of "Heartbeat" playing the thief/butler who counsels Arlette when she needs it most.As for the opening episodes with Basil Rathbone, playing a sort of Fagin to a motley group of over-aged delinquents, these scenes serve to introduce Arlette as a most extraordinary young lady, indeed. She actually manages to fool Professor Aristide himself, the expert schemer and arch criminal of them all! A spectacularly funny cameo for Sherlock Holmes!Far from suffering through this film, let alone finding it boring, I was immensely entertained to the very end. The 'Hollywood ending' was really not predictable. In a film like this, anything could have happened.The whole fantasy was delightfully bubbly, like pink champagne.