At first rather annoying in its heavy emphasis on reenactments, this movie ultimately proves fascinating, simply because the complicated, highly dramatic tale it tells still almost defies belief.

Blistering performances.

The movie's neither hopeful in contrived ways, nor hopeless in different contrived ways. Somehow it manages to be wonderful

The biggest problem with this movie is it’s a little better than you think it might be, which somehow makes it worse. As in, it takes itself a bit too seriously, which makes most of the movie feel kind of dull.

RATHER THAN BEING classified as a cartoon (which it obviously is), this very brief 3 minutes of animated drawings could well be called a sort of Soundie. Although the term is not widely known today, Soundies were filmed versions of popular song forms.BEING PRODUVED IN the 16 mm format and lasting about the length of a single recording (approximately 3 minutes in length), their venue was in that of specially equipped juke boxes that were equipped to show the short and the sound track for a nickel or a dime a play.WELL ALL OF the above qualifications can be and are those of this FROSTY THE SNOWMAN b & w cartoon. But of course, rather than being played on a juke box in some gin mill, FROSTY was ,made for and thrived on Television; where he continues to this very day.THE STYLE OF artwork in both the character design and the backgrounds is quite familiar to those who were around when the animated short was given a new direction in 1943 with the emergence of the United Productions of America or UPA for short and one prefers anagrams. UPA pioneered the stylized look of scenery and character' positing that Disney-style realism was not necessary for successful. Former Disney artist, John Hubley, was a principal partner in the formation of this studio..EARLY SUCCESSES FROM this company include GERALD Mc BOING-BOING and the MISTER MAGOO theatrical series. They didn't do much in the way of television until around 1960 with their entries of MR. MAGOO TV Series and the DICK TRACY Show (featuring the voice of Mercury Theatre veteran Everett Sloan!) FROSTY THE SNOWMAN appears to have been their first venture into the small screen.AS WE HAVE previously stated, FROSTY is short and to the point. It is not constructed in various vignettes or gag scenes. It quite possibly is the best cartoon of its genre, pound for pound or foot for foot (of film that is, Schultz!)

Frosty the Snowman (1954) *** 1/2 (out of 4)This timeless short originally aired on a Chicago station and has since become a favorite to many. At just under 3-minutes there's really no story being told outside of the song itself. We see a group of kids dancing around the snowman and as soon as they put the hat on him he begins to dance as well. There are so many Christmas shorts out there that one could get lost in trying to track all of them down but many are very much worth it and that's the case with this one. I think most people are going to be familiar with the more recent, color films but seeing a Christmas cartoon in B&W just adds a timeless quality to it. I really loved the animation here and especially the look of Frosty. I hope this comes out the right way but he looks like what a real snowman would look like if a bunch of kids just put it together in the back yard. In many Frosty cartoons he looks like, well, a fake cartoon but in this version he really does look like a snowman.

I recently discovered on Mark Evanier's site as linked from Cartoon Brew a couple of UPA animated holiday shorts that are on YouTube. One was Peter Cottontail which for some reason is not listed on IMDb. That one played the whole song and depicted visually the entire premise down to the hunter that shot the rabbit's tail. This one, Frosty the Snowman, features the title character's fun with some kids before he leaves so he won't melt away. Both had a chorus that featured no musical accompaniment, just them singing in the standard jazzy style of the period. These were longtime annual staples on Chicago kid shows for years. As a longtime animation fan, these were pleasant surprises. Definitely worth a look.

This peppy, jazzed up cartoon of the frosty story was shown on kiddie T.V. along with the cult holiday stop motion favorites, "Suzie snowflake" and "Hardrock, Coco and Joe." Not as interesting as it's two sister films, it's still quite likable, and captures the fifties "lets go out to the lobby" school of animation quite nicely. Great holiday nostalgia bait. What else can I say? I guess I have to make this longer to get accepted. No one, to the best of my knowledge, ever used this cartoon as an excuse to go on a vicious crime spree. Long enough yet? I guess not. O.K., well, let me just say I rather watch this short cartoon than the whole half hour Rankin Bass version. They really cut to the chase here.