For all the hype it got I was expecting a lot more!

everything you have heard about this movie is true.

Admirable film.

While it doesn't offer any answers, it both thrills and makes you think.

I didn't have high expectation from the movie but whatever little i had its even fail to pass on that. I watched one Pakistani Movie BOL after one friend of mine from Pakistan suggested me and i really liked that. however after that whatever Pakistani Movie i watched they were all crap i am not even able to watch them fully. This Movie at least was looking appealing but there is nothing in it. Worst acting except Zaba Bakhtiyar, she still looks good better than the lead actress Mahira other actress looks good but don't how to act. Hero is a big disaster, Its funny to see that guy can't even deserve a character artist role but has been given a opportunity to romance with two girls. Direction is also bad, editing was pathetic however location in this movie are quite good and thats the only good point i found. Hope to see a good Pakistani film next time.

Movie contains some very good acting cast. Mahira Khan really did a marvelous job along side with Hamyun Saeed and others. Movie has an excellent set of songs made played really on right situation. Director has done a very good work. Shiraz Uppal has done a very good job in making the music of the movie , you really enjoy the songs. Movie is made realistic and sports common life in Pakistan. In short it is a must watch for Pakistani drama loving audience and other who enjoy love stories written very beautifully. If you will try to keep going with the story you will really enjoy the movie. You cannot miss movies like this if you support cinema in Pakistan.

Pakistani Cinema is currently in the process of making a name for itself. As such, this movie provides an excellent opportunity and platform to grow further and build upon. Critics may point out that cinema in Pakistan has been at it for years. Churning out one forgettable title after another. It is true that once-upon-a-time, Lahore was a center for great cinematic productions; And the last 30 years of cinema in Pakistan have witnessed a slow and steady decline. Both in quality and the sheer numbers of films made. This film changes that, and this is why a film like "Bin Roye" is an important milestone. ** Warning ** Contains Spoilers ** The movie (almost entirely) centers around Mahira Khan, and she has done well to do justice to the role. The dialogue and story line have a couple of weak links (no major plot holes), but overall, the concept and execution are apt. Without spoiling the movie for fans, its a treat to watch on the big screen, and the quality of the production is on par with current international titles as can be judged by the sudden accident scene, which is second only to the one done in "Meet Joe Black". There are three key take aways from this film. First and foremost, Films from Pakistan have the possibility to carve a spot of their own on the International film arena based on a niche that is not yet fully explored. This film only scratches the surface of what else may be possible. In short, greater films can be done. Secondly, It is a greatly refreshing experience to walk into a movie theater without the apprehension of witnessing indecent or vulgar cinema. Art in its most beautiful form is pure, enlightening, dignified and entertaining. Its good to see movies that promote that. Finally, and last-but-not-the-least; We are capable of exploring subjects that have not yet been opened up by others. This uniqueness, this individuality, as "Bin Roye" has aptly explored, holds a promise for a future that is bright for Cinema. The subject of this film may be the run of the mill romance and just-another-form of unrequited love, but the depth of expression and the display of emotions surrounding this melodrama are so unique in a cultural context, that the film "Bin Roye" manages to carve a genre on its own. This is a key strength, and this innovation to directly invoke and display culture through film is an enlightening experience. As a movie fan, I enjoy experiences that I can relate with, and a film close to my culture, is the one that is dear to the heart and soul. Momina Duraid has opened a door, and if future films follow this path, there can only be greater fame and success.

Great job by the fledgling Paki film industry (i.e. Lollywood is not to be counted as part of the current wave. This ain't no lolly! This is Pak TV transformed for the Widescreen!)I always knew the "BUDGET" is not a factor to justify the crappy lollywood productions. Excellent work from a good team. This of course needs further improvement, but excellent progress in such a short span of time.. The cinema house in Sydney was PACKED.. this doesn't happen often.. not even for Bollywood..I can see everyone loved Mahira Khan's acting but to me she has the same style of acting everywhere which sometimes makes it a bit monotonous.. but nonetheless this is good entertainment..