Withered occultist Mr. Petrulo runs a New York-style deli in middle of nowhere Wyoming with his team of misfit deli warriors -- Horace, Sandra, and Lily -- as well as useless manchild Ralphie. In the pilot, Ralphie falls into a pocket dimension inside the deli's dumpster and is seduced by a trash-dwelling succubus who lures in "white male saviors" and steals their souls. It's up to Horace to rush in and save him -- but he himself has a checkered past with the succubus, and when his wife Sandra discovers that Horace ventured into the dumpster, she recruits Lily to go with her to dole out her righteous vengeance.